Troy reviews

The 2016 Asia Drama Tragedy 🚫R

Silence


By Martin Scorcese, Jay Cocks, Shūsaku Endō, Andrew Garfield, Liam N



brain rating
TROY SAYS:

Great 7.9

"PROs: No profanity. No sex. Faithfully depicts the dilemma faced by Christians in non-Christian countries—in this case, the Kakure Kirishitan (‘Hidden Christians’) of Japan. Beautiful cinematography. Superb acting.

CONs: Lots of brutal killings. Confuses Catholicism with Christianity. Probably presents Jesuit priests in a better-than-realistic light. Ends down, after spending 2 hours building up the expectation that the priest will honor his faith, the priest apostatizes and lives out his life in shame and sadness."

heart rating
GENIE SAYS:

Good 6.9

“Incredibly disturbing. Extreme emotional letdown.”

AVERAGE RATING: 7.4

out of 10




Silence on Wikipedia